The contrasting perspectives of Adrian Wieczorek and Elizabeth MacLeod on plant cognition and consciousness reveal a deep divide in how we understand plant life. Wieczorek argues that plants lack the cognitive or perceptual capacities to be considered conscious beings. We do not need to appreciate plants if they are not cognizant. He contends that plants react mechanically to stimuli without any intentionality or awareness, and without facing informational variety or ambiguity in their responses, labeling their actions as cognitive or perceptual is unwarranted.
On the other hand, MacLeod presents a different worldview, suggesting that if plant neurobiology can demonstrate cognition-like responses, then it is plausible to consider plants as possessing a form of consciousness. She argues that plants have a sense of agency, and, like other living beings, their inherent dignity should be acknowledged and preserved. This perspective aligns with the views of Florianne Koechlin, who, as part of the Swiss Federal Ethics Committee on Non-Human Biotechnology, argued for the legal recognition of plant dignity, raising important ethical questions about our obligations toward plant life and their rights within the broader framework of biocentrism.
The question is, who has the burden of proof? Do we need to prove plant consciousness beyond a doubt in order to recognize it or would it be more ethical to acknowledge it, then if science feels strongly that it is not true, disprove it?
Topics covered about appreciating plants
Human acknowledgement of plant dignity
How do you tell if plants are simply sensors or if we are incapable of seeing kin’s worth?
Who has the burden of proving cognition?
Commentary on appreciating plants within Naturally Conscious Community:
LIVE Plant Consciousness Commentary every Friday
Where we explore all things plant neurobiology, plant cognition, plant intelligence, plant humanities, and the birth of critical plant studies through the lens of personal evolution. Livestreams are every Friday on Youtube and the Naturally Conscious Community.
Be a part of the conversation in the Naturally Conscious Community
Let’s talk more in the only online ecosystem that nourishes plant reawakening for enhanced evolution and collaboration with our plant friends. Connect with nature-conscious creatives, multipotentialites, and naturentrepreneurs who share your desire to see beauty in the world. >> JOIN OUR COMMUNITY <<
Looking for a mentor/coach to help you confidently embody a Naturally Conscious Life? Book a discovery call here, and let’s discuss how I can support you.
We use information collected through cookies and similar technologies to improve your experience on our site, analyse how you use it and for marketing purposes.
We and our partners use information collected through cookies and similar technologies to improve your experience on our site, analyse how you use it and for marketing purposes. Because we respect your right to privacy, you can choose not to allow some types of cookies. However, blocking some types of cookies may impact your experience of the site and the services we are able to offer. In some cases, data obtained from cookies is shared with third parties for analytics or marketing reasons. You can exercise your right to opt-out of that sharing at any time by disabling cookies.
These cookies and scripts are necessary for the website to function and cannot be switched off. They are usually only set in response to actions made by you which amount to a request for services, suchas setting your privacy preferences, logging in or filling in forms. You can set your browser to block oralert you about these cookies, but some parts of the site will not then work. These cookies do not store any personally identifiable information.
Analytics
These cookies and scripts allow us to count visits and traffic sources, so we can measure and improve the performance of our site. They help us know which pages are the most and least popular and see how visitors move around the site. All information these cookies collect is aggregated and therefore anonymous. If you do not allow these cookies and scripts, we will not know when you have visited our site.
Embedded Videos
These cookies and scripts may be set through our site by external video hosting services likeYouTube or Vimeo. They may be used to deliver video content on our website. It’s possible for the video provider to build a profile of your interests and show you relevant adverts on this or other websites. They do not store directly personal information, but are based on uniquely identifying your browser and internet device. If you do not allow these cookies or scripts it is possible that embedded video will not function as expected.
Google Fonts
Google Fonts is a font embedding service library. Google Fonts are stored on Google's CDN. The Google Fonts API is designed to limit the collection, storage, and use of end-user data to only what is needed to serve fonts efficiently. Use of Google Fonts API is unauthenticated. No cookies are sent by website visitors to the Google Fonts API. Requests to the Google Fonts API are made to resource-specific domains, such as fonts.googleapis.com or fonts.gstatic.com. This means your font requests are separate from and don't contain any credentials you send to google.com while using other Google services that are authenticated, such as Gmail.
Marketing
These cookies and scripts may be set through our site by our advertising partners. They may be used by those companies to build a profile of your interests and show you relevant adverts on other sites. They do not store directly personal information, but are based on uniquely identifying your browser and internet device. If you do not allow these cookies and scripts, you will experience less targeted advertising.
Facebook Advanced Matching
Facebook Advanced Matching can improve ads attribution and conversion tracking. It can help us reach better-targeted custom audiences through our ads. When possible, we will share with Facebook hashed information like your name, phone, email, or address.
Facebook CAPI
Facebook Conversion API Events (CAPI) help us better understand how you interact with our websites. They allow us to measure the impact of our ads on the website's conversions and they improve ads targeting through custom audiences. When possible, we might share with Facebook information like name, email, phone, address.
Tigrilla Gardenia
Should We Be Obligated to Appreciate Plants for Their Own Sake?
The contrasting perspectives of Adrian Wieczorek and Elizabeth MacLeod on plant cognition and consciousness reveal a deep divide in how we understand plant life. Wieczorek argues that plants lack the cognitive or perceptual capacities to be considered conscious beings. We do not need to appreciate plants if they are not cognizant. He contends that plants react mechanically to stimuli without any intentionality or awareness, and without facing informational variety or ambiguity in their responses, labeling their actions as cognitive or perceptual is unwarranted.
On the other hand, MacLeod presents a different worldview, suggesting that if plant neurobiology can demonstrate cognition-like responses, then it is plausible to consider plants as possessing a form of consciousness. She argues that plants have a sense of agency, and, like other living beings, their inherent dignity should be acknowledged and preserved. This perspective aligns with the views of Florianne Koechlin, who, as part of the Swiss Federal Ethics Committee on Non-Human Biotechnology, argued for the legal recognition of plant dignity, raising important ethical questions about our obligations toward plant life and their rights within the broader framework of biocentrism.
The question is, who has the burden of proof? Do we need to prove plant consciousness beyond a doubt in order to recognize it or would it be more ethical to acknowledge it, then if science feels strongly that it is not true, disprove it?
Topics covered about appreciating plants
Commentary on appreciating plants within Naturally Conscious Community:
LIVE Plant Consciousness Commentary every Friday
Where we explore all things plant neurobiology, plant cognition, plant intelligence, plant humanities, and the birth of critical plant studies through the lens of personal evolution. Livestreams are every Friday on Youtube and the Naturally Conscious Community.
Be a part of the conversation in the Naturally Conscious Community
Let’s talk more in the only online ecosystem that nourishes plant reawakening for enhanced evolution and collaboration with our plant friends. Connect with nature-conscious creatives, multipotentialites, and naturentrepreneurs who share your desire to see beauty in the world. >> JOIN OUR COMMUNITY <<
Get to Know Me, Tigrilla Gardenia
WORKING TOGETHER:
COURSES and PROGRAMS:
Memberships:
Looking for a mentor/coach to help you confidently embody a Naturally Conscious Life? Book a discovery call here, and let’s discuss how I can support you.
Episodes related vegetal kinship
The Sentience of Plants: Animal Rights and Rights of Nature Intersecting?
Plants are intelligent, here’s how
References
Wieczorek, Adrian. 2021. Why deceived systems do not need to be cognitive. Reply to Artiga. (International Conference “Green Intelligence? – Debating Plant Cognition”, Basle 2021)
MacLeod, E. 2022. Plant Neurobiology Can Prove Plant Consciousness. CIIS Cohort F Spring, Field Reader.
If you have a paper, essay, article, or video you would like me to comment on, send it to me!
Share this post